Tea_Honey
|
![[*]](./images/Pinky/default_icon.gif) posted on 5.4.2011 at 01:51 PM |
|
|
It's Obama's victory!
If bin Laden's assassination had gone badly, he would have been blamed. That's why he gets the credit.
posted on May 4, 2011, at 12:36 PM
The story goes that after the Bay of Pigs disaster, President Kennedy placed a call to CIA director Allen Dulles. Kennedy supposedly said: "If we
lived in a parliamentary system, and I were prime minister, after a disaster of this magnitude I'd have to resign. But we don't. So you do."
Probably the story has been improved on over the years. But there's a core of truth there, which is that there is a lot of fiction in the idea of
presidential leadership.
The president of the United States is often described as the world's most powerful man. It seldom feels that way to him. A lot of the reality of the
presidency is summed up by that amazing White House Situation Room photograph of the senior national security staff tensely watching the Sunday attack
on the bin Laden compound.
Look at President Obama's face. Tense. Anxious. The face of a man who knows his presidency is riding on events unfolding on the other side of the
planet, which he can no longer shape or guide.
He has made a few key decisions. He decided in favor of a commando raid against a bombing attack. He decided to disregard the presence of women and
children. He decided that bin Laden should be killed rather than captured for trial.
Beyond that, his role was mostly to accept operational decisions made by appropriate professionals. But of course he is not a professional himself.
When the question is posed: four helicopters or five? What kind of explosive charge to use to stun the residents at the start of the raid? What
measures to counter-act Pakistani radar? Or even -- how much confidence can we have that bin Laden is actually there? To those questions, a president
(any president) brings only the instincts, the experience, and the expertise of the career politician. That's what he is, after all.
There is however one other thing a president brings to any major national decision: the knowledge that if things go wrong, it is he who will receive
the blame.
This rule of is not absolute. An especially skillful politician can sometimes escape blame, as Ronald Reagan did after the Marine barracks bombing in
Beirut. But the more normal outcome is what happened to Jimmy Carter after the humiliating hostage rescue attempt in Iran or what happened to Bill
Clinton after the "Blackhawk Down" disaster in Mogadishu: Ferocious criticism at a minimum, re-election defeat at a maximum. If it's bad, we blame
the man at the top.
And that's the answer to those who question why Barack Obama should get any credit for a mission that succeeded because of the planning decisions of
senior commanders and the courage, skill and marksmanship of Special Forces and CIA professionals whose names we may never know. It's very rough
justice, but that's the only kind of justice presidents typically can expect.
| Quote: |
If bin Laden's assassination had gone badly, he would have been blamed. That's why he gets the credit.
|
'Nuff said. 
(except:  ) [/color]
|
|
|
Homegirl 50
|
| posted on 5.7.2011 at 02:11 PM |
|
|
"If bin Laden's assassination had gone badly, he would have been blamed. That's why he gets the credit."
Yep enough said.
When other people make mistakes, we seek justice.
When we make mistakes, we seek compassion.
The lesson is to give to others what you seek.
--Maura Cullen
|
|
|
Black Maverick
|
| posted on 5.9.2011 at 08:16 PM |
|
|
I don't see why we should celebrate the Emperor of the empire. Instead of capturing Osama Bin Laden and making an argument to become signatories of
the International Criminal Court (and had Bin Laden tried there), we executed him to puff our chest at the world. Cool....Obama killed someone in a
ideological war that has nothing to do with terrorism...
Free Mumia Abu Jamal
|
|
|
Tea_Honey
|
| posted on 5.9.2011 at 10:33 PM |
|
|
The emperor of what empire? Who's puffing their chest at the world? Why is it "cool" that Obama had someone executed?
Either deal with the subject - Obama carried out a risky adventure and had it gone badly, he would have been blamed, and the ONLY one blamed - or take
that tripe to another thread.
|
|
|
Portal 
Search 
FAQ 
Member List 
Topic Activity 
Stats 
Board Rules 
